A Critical Assessment of Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim

Ayatollah Seyed Ali Hosseini Milani

Back Cover

You are previewing: A Critical Assessment of Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim

A Critical Assessment of Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim

Ayatollah Seyed Ali Hosseini Milani
Author

Ayatollah Seyed Ali Hosseini Milani

Useful Reviews

  1. Your review is awaiting approval

    wettbüro quoten

    Feel free to surf to my website … wetten online bonus ohne
    einzahlung (Bradley)

  2. Your review is awaiting approval

    was sind buchmacher

    Stop by my blog … Bester anbieter Sportwetten

  3. Your review is awaiting approval

    welche wettanbieter haben eine deutsche lizenz

    Here is my webpage … Wetten bonus übersicht

  4. Your review is awaiting approval

    wettanbieter curacao

    my page; Wettseiten mit Startguthaben, https://Clients.Prontodigital.Com/peach-electric/wett-tipp-osterreich-nordmazedonien-2,

  5. Your review is awaiting approval

    wettbüro leverkusen – http://www.grandfol.pl – berlin reinickendorf

  6. Your review is awaiting approval

    bet live wetten spiele (https://Www.Efora.it/2025/10/10/Eishockey-live-wetten)

  7. Your review is awaiting approval

    paypal Neue Sportwetten Bonus

  8. Your review is awaiting approval

    beste wettstrategie sportwetten

    My web-site; wetten prognose heute [Adam]

  9. Your review is awaiting approval

    sichere wetten rechner

    My webpage – Kombiwette Absichern

  10. Your review is awaiting approval

    sport wetten tipps heute

    Feel free to surf to my site … sportwetten strategie

  11. Your review is awaiting approval

    online wettbüro

    Check out my homepage: muss man Bei Einer kombiwette alles richtig haben

  12. Your review is awaiting approval

    beste app top sportwetten

  13. Your review is awaiting approval

    sportwetten forum tipps

    my web-site – wette ergebnisse – Tesouromodaintima.com.br,

  14. Your review is awaiting approval

    wett tipps heute net

    Feel free to visit my website … legale Sportwetten schweiz

  15. Your review is awaiting approval

    wett tipps über unter tore

    Take a look at my website Wette Deutschland Frankreich

  16. Your review is awaiting approval

    geburtstermin wette gewinn

    my web-site; Quote Bei Wetten

  17. Your review is awaiting approval

    wettanbieter mit gratiswette mit bonus ohne einzahlung

  18. Your review is awaiting approval

    eigenes wettbüro eröffnen

    Also visit my web page; internet wetten bonus

  19. Your review is awaiting approval

    sportwetten online schweiz

    Also visit my homepage: gratiswette ohne einzahlung sofort (https://veritasphysio.ie/online-wetten-neue-anbieter)

  20. Your review is awaiting approval

    sportwetten online vergleich livescore

  21. Your review is awaiting approval

    handicap Wette erklärt wetten bedeutung

  22. Your review is awaiting approval

    sportwetten vergleich bonus

    Feel free to visit my page; die besten wett apps

  23. Your review is awaiting approval

    neueste wettanbieter

    Feel free to surf to my homepage perfekte Wettstrategie

  24. Your review is awaiting approval

    beste sportwetten app schweiz (Judi) sportwetten anbieter österreich

  25. Your review is awaiting approval

    sportwetten online mit bonus

    Also visit my web blog … wett tipps heute basketball

  26. Your review is awaiting approval

    wett quoten

    My web site :: neue buchmacher

  27. Your review is awaiting approval

    esport live sichere wetten heute (https://Www.torresrl.it/)

  28. Your review is awaiting approval

    sport und wetten

    Also visit my site wettbüRo us wahl

  29. Your review is awaiting approval

    are casino winnings taxed in australia, bonauka malaysia
    4d gambling; Shanon, machine and free online united kingdom casino,
    or quatro casino united states

  30. Your review is awaiting approval

    famous united statesn poker, gambling revenue canada and raging bull parx casino nj app
    canada, or united statesn casinos still accepting skrill

  31. Your review is awaiting approval

    play online poker united states, australian online pokies minimum $5 deposit
    and canada casino download free game, or online bingo for prizes in uk

    My webpage big win on roulette (Hai)

  32. Your review is awaiting approval

    blackjack united kingdom general, gambling stocks in united states and craps
    gambling uk, or best online casino sites for real money canada

    Feel free to visit my blog biloxi casinos Destroyed by katrina

  33. Your review is awaiting approval

    no deposit australian pokies, free bonus casino no deposit required canada Define Investment Speculation And Gambling best free slots united states, or
    cash bingo australia

  34. Your review is awaiting approval

    gambling affiliates usa, new casino sites not uk and bingo
    1-90 online (Verna) casinos that accept apple
    pay usa, or australia casino lasseters

  35. Your review is awaiting approval

    gambling in canada statistics, no deposit sign up bonus nz 2021 and best online ess login gateway
    casino (Jermaine) payout uk, or gambling sites usa

  36. Your review is awaiting approval

    top 10 online casinos in canada, free bonus no deposit casino usa 2021
    and free imatant spins no deposit bonus united states,
    or free united statesn slot machine games

    my web blog: blackjack uk rapper (Nina#)

  37. Your review is awaiting approval

    xpokies no deposit bonus codes australia 2021, online trusted casino usa and free bingo games
    united states, or poker usa tournaments

    Look into my web blog goplayslots.net

  38. Your review is awaiting approval

    online casino united states that accept paysafe, slot machine bases canada and 21 dukes casino review,
    or free spins casino no deposit bonus united states

    Also visit my blog :: Worst Casinos In America

  39. Your review is awaiting approval

    latest online casinos canada, online casino review usa
    and pokies real money united states, or uk slot sites not on gamstop

    Also visit my web page – how to gamble legally (Rene)

  40. Your review is awaiting approval

    united kingdom live god 88 casino (Malinda), canadian poker admiral and new zealandn online pokies bonus, or £10 no deposit
    slot bonus uk 2021

  41. Your review is awaiting approval

    wett tipps ergebnisse

    Also visit my page comment-264388

  42. Your review is awaiting approval

    buchmacher köln

    Feel free to surf to my site comment-22236 [Alda]

  43. Your review is awaiting approval

    beste wettanbieter test betrugstest

    Here is my page :: WettbüRo

  44. Your review is awaiting approval

    bester bonus wettanbieter

    Feel free to visit my website – daglfing pferderennen wetten – Rigoberto,

  45. Your review is awaiting approval

    wett tipps ai kosten

    My webpage sportwetten anbieter ohne Lugas

  46. Your review is awaiting approval

    quoten von wetten dass

    Here is my web-site; sportwetten bonus paypal

  47. Your review is awaiting approval

    wettbüro lübeck

    My webpage: sport-wetten

  48. Your review is awaiting approval

    was heißt quote bei wetten

    Take a look at my page … sportwetten mit startguthaben ohne einzahlung (Audiomack.com)

  49. Your review is awaiting approval

    sportwetten strategie pdf anbieter
    liste

  50. Your review is awaiting approval

    sportwetten vergleich quoten

    Also visit my page; wetten deutschland dänemark (http://www.twitch.tv)

  51. Your review is awaiting approval

    quote sichere wetten strategie (Vince) bedeutung

  52. Your review is awaiting approval

    die besten sportwetten bonus

    Feel free to visit my website: buchmacher london (Chang)

  53. Your review is awaiting approval

    sportwetten anbieter österreich

    Look at my site: Esc Buchmacher

  54. Your review is awaiting approval

    esc wetten portugal deutschland wettquoten

  55. Your review is awaiting approval

    seriöse sportwetten anbieter

    Also visit my web page: Wetten handicap

  56. Your review is awaiting approval

    halbzeit endstand wetten

    Also visit my website :: die besten sportwetten Strategien

  57. Your review is awaiting approval

    wetten ergebnisse vorhersage

    Feel free to surf to my webpage :: vorhersagen sportwetten [Greta]

  58. Your review is awaiting approval

    online sportwetten app

    My web blog – Buchmacher Pferdewetten

  59. Your review is awaiting approval

    sportwetten online mit bonus

    Here is my web page … Ausbildung Buchmacher

  60. Your review is awaiting approval

    sportwetten Deutscher anbieter strategie unentschieden

  61. Your review is awaiting approval

    wettanbieter lizenz

    Feel free to visit my site … Was Passiert Wenn Beim Wetten Ein Spiel Abgesagt Wird, Luma.Com,

  62. Your review is awaiting approval

    sportwetten anbieten

    Look into my blog post … comment-663363 (Dean)

  63. Your review is awaiting approval

    deutschland wetten

    Review my homepage: besten sportwetten apps; https://www.newdirectionchildcarefacility.com,

  64. Your review is awaiting approval

    wettseiten mit bonus

    My page: Online wette

  65. Your review is awaiting approval

    ohne einzahlung Neue Sportwetten Seiten

  66. Your review is awaiting approval

    ohne einzahlung bonus sportwetten Ohne Einzahlung bonus

  67. Your review is awaiting approval

    wetten internet

    Feel free to visit my website; wettanbieter Im test

  68. Your review is awaiting approval

    vermittler von Ungarn Deutschland Wetten [Jobs.Lifewest.Edu] bei pferderennen

  69. Your review is awaiting approval

    wettstrategie unentschieden

    Stop by my webpage bwin darts wetten

  70. Your review is awaiting approval

    geburtstermin wette gewinn

    my web site – basketball-wetten.com

  71. Your review is awaiting approval

    play pokies online free canada, gambling stocks in united states and how to make
    a casino roulette (Jed) bonus usa, or
    50 free spins thunderstruck no deposit usa

  72. Your review is awaiting approval

    9k3w2b

  73. Your review is awaiting approval

    g8d0bb

  74. Your review is awaiting approval

    wz5ibr

  75. Your review is awaiting approval

    5pyqd1

  76. Your review is awaiting approval

    k8l4ms

  77. Your review is awaiting approval

    dhtmql

  78. Your review is awaiting approval

    414yr9

  79. Your review is awaiting approval

    ta8g2w

  80. Your review is awaiting approval

    o2w22x

  81. Your review is awaiting approval

    ta9c01

  82. Your review is awaiting approval

    lvlxyq

  83. Your review is awaiting approval

    pn6lu8

  84. Your review is awaiting approval

    jr0l2j

  85. Your review is awaiting approval

    3jda50

  86. Your review is awaiting approval

    22bpu4

  87. Your review is awaiting approval

    xhqdw5

  88. Your review is awaiting approval

    2gerjv

  89. Your review is awaiting approval

    uaac9s

  90. Your review is awaiting approval

    bxlvje

  91. Your review is awaiting approval

    a4sfr6

  92. Your review is awaiting approval

    ebufb8

  93. Your review is awaiting approval

    v96plw

  94. Your review is awaiting approval

    ijz2jb

  95. Your review is awaiting approval

    upr12n

  96. Your review is awaiting approval

    vdzoxb

  97. Your review is awaiting approval

    ida8cw

  98. Your review is awaiting approval

    gnvgm1

  99. Your review is awaiting approval

    47i8mh

  100. Your review is awaiting approval

    vkm6m7

  101. Your review is awaiting approval

    Pretty nice post. I juist stumbled upon yoour blog and widhed
    to saay tht I’ve truly njoyed browsing your blog posts.
    In anyy case I’ll be subscribikng tto our rsss feeed and I
    hope you write agai very soon!

    Look into my page … missav xxx

  102. Your review is awaiting approval

    kz9qok

  103. Your review is awaiting approval

    guwr7p

  104. Your review is awaiting approval

    4vms5b

Back Cover

Related Products

You may also like…

A Critical Assessment of Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim is a scholarly work by Ayatollah Sayyid Ali al-Husayni al-Milani that rigorously analyzes the authenticity of hadiths in the most revered Sunni collections. The book challenges the notion that every narration in Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim is reliable and authentic, shedding light on fabricated and weak narrations that have been misrepresented as part of the authentic Islamic tradition.

Examining the Narrators and Their Reliability

The book provides a detailed critique of the narrators cited by both Bukhari and Muslim, including key figures such as Ibn Hajar Asqalani, Abu Zur’ah, and Abu Hatam.

Category: Tags: , ,

Description

A Critical Assessment of Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim is a scholarly work by Ayatollah Sayyid Ali al-Husayni al-Milani that rigorously analyzes the authenticity of hadiths in the most revered Sunni collections. The book challenges the notion that every narration in Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim is reliable and authentic, shedding light on fabricated and weak narrations that have been misrepresented as part of the authentic Islamic tradition.

Examining the Narrators and Their Reliability

The book provides a detailed critique of the narrators cited by both Bukhari and Muslim, including key figures such as Ibn Hajar Asqalani, Abu Zur’ah, and Abu Hatam. It addresses their biases, their credibility, and their criticism of other narrators, particularly those from the Ahl al-Bayt (the family of the Prophet). Through this critical examination, Ayatollah al-Milani argues that not all narrations in these collections are free from error or fabrication.

Misleading Narrations in Sahih Collections

In Part One, the author addresses specific narrations in Sahih al-Bukhari, such as the marriage proposal to Aisha and the intercession of Ibrahim for Azar, pointing out logical inconsistencies and historical errors in these accounts. The book also critiques Bukhari’s treatment of the Ghadir narration and its significance, arguing that Sahih al-Bukhari misrepresents the legacy of Imam Ali and the Ahl al-Bayt.

Unveiling the Truth: Sahih Muslim

Part Two turns to Sahih Muslim, exposing false traditions and highlighting the political undertones behind some narrations. It critically evaluates the transmission of narrations related to figures like Abu Talib and the caliphate of Abu Bakr, calling attention to how these narrations have influenced Sunni-Shia relations over time.

Legacy and Impact

This book presents a broader theological and political discourse on the implications of these misrepresented narrations in shaping Islamic thought. It is a must-read for scholars, students of Islamic studies, and those interested in understanding the complex historical layers of Islamic narrations, particularly those from the Sahih collections.

Author Picture

Ayatollah Seyed Ali Hosseini Milani

Ayatollah Haj Seyed Ali Hosseini Milani, born in 1975 in Najaf, comes from a distinguished scholarly family. He studied in Karbala, Najaf, Qom, and Mashhad under prominent scholars, including Ayatollah Mousavi Golpaygani and Ayatollah Vahid Khorasani. He now teaches advanced Islamic jurisprudence (fiqh) and principles (usul) at the Qom Seminary and has specialized in Islamic theology. Throughout his career, he has authored numerous works in Islamic studies, which have been translated into 12 languages. His wide-reaching translations have helped spread his knowledge and influence in Islamic theology globally.

Reviews

Reviews

There are no reviews yet.

Be the first to review “A Critical Assessment of Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim”

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may also like…

Buy product

Questions and Answers on the Virtues and Sufferings of Lady Zahra (peace be upon her)

Ayatollah Seyyed Mohammad Sadegh Hosseini Rohani
Quick View
Buy product

The Prophet Muhammad a Mercy to the Worlds

Ayatollah Sayyid Muhammad Shirazi
Quick View
Buy product

THE MYSTERY OF THE SHI’A

Shaykh Mateen Adam Charbonneau
Quick View
Buy product

Essence of Insight

Ayatollah Sayyid Muhammad Shirazi
Quick View

Related Products

Buy product

Death- The Beginning of Life

Ayatollah Sayyid Muhammad Ridha Shirazi
Quick View
Buy product

Foundations of Faith: Lectures on the Core Beliefs of Islam through the Teachings of the Ahl ul Bayt

Shaykh Mateen Adam Charbonneau
Quick View
Buy product

An Exegesis on The Daily Supplications of The Holy Month of Ramadan

Shaykh Abdul Karim Al-Haeri
Quick View
Buy product

Islam: The Religion of Life

Ayatollah Seyed Mohammad-Taqi al-Modarresi
Quick View